11/11/2023 0 Comments Dolphin emulator no soundOne of the few things the DMCA does make clear is that circumventing copyright protection is prohibited, which is why Nintendo's letter to Valve specifically cites Dolphin's use of cryptographic keys. Everyone who cares does know that it operates (and has always operated) in a gray area though." Lawyers, courts, emulation developers, Nintendo - no-one. "Like, people can't fathom that *nobody* has a clue whether emulators for 7th gen consoles might be infringing DMCA anti-circumvention clauses. "One interesting realization for me with the recent Dolphin / Valve / Nintendo situation is how little people understand the ambiguity of US copyright laws," delroth said. There are few hard rules about what is and isn't allowed. You just couldn't download the same game from the internet.īut the reason that we're talking about 'interpretation' and 'belief' here is that breaking copyright law is not like making a traffic violation. Under this interpretation of the law, you could fire up a PlayStation emulator, stick an official PS1 disc in your PC's CD drive, and enjoy the game without fear that you're breaking the law. Decades ago, the developers of a commercially-sold PlayStation emulator called Bleem! successfully defended themselves from Sony's allegations of copyright infringement. It's widely believed among emulation advocates that emulators themselves are perfectly legal, and they may be right. The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom Notably, Nintendo has seemingly ignored the existence of popular Switch emulators even after they were widely used to play Tears of the Kingdom before the game was even officially out. In fact, Nintendo has never taken action against Dolphin directly, and while Nintendo's action against software pirates is notoriously harsh, it typically hasn't gone after the emulators that can be used to play pirated software. The key detail here is that Nintendo has taken no action against Dolphin or its developers - it simply responded to Valve's request for information. Nintendo said no, citing its belief that Dolphin would violate the DMCA by using "cryptographic keys without Nintendo’s authorization and decrypting the ROMs at or immediately before runtime." Valve then chose to delist Dolphin from Steam, and forwarded the letter to the Dolphin devs - and, because of an error in addressing the message, the letter also went to delroth. Former Dolphin developer delroth said on Mastodon that, to the best of his understanding, Valve reached out to Nintendo about whether or not it was cool to host the emulator on Steam.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |